- They are a distraction to both teachers and other students' learning
- Cell phones can also be used to cheat on tests
- Not all students will have access to a cell phone
- Difficult to monitor what students are doing on their cell phone
1. Technology is our future and it seems only a matter of time cell phone use will be encouraged in the classroom. Many cell phones today are more of a computer than a phone. I believe it makes sense to begin to incorporate the use of cell phones in class to help keep students interested and to make students aware of the capabilities of how they could use their cell phone for learning. Instead of focusing on the distractions cell phones cause, maybe we should focus on how they could be used to benefit student learning. For example, in its simplest form, a smart phone can be used to take notes or used as calculators in class.
2.Using cell phones in class could improve student excitement in the classroom. I think many students would rather walk into a classroom knowing will be using their cell phone as a learning tool in class. For example, have students use their phone to answer a bell ringer, or take part in a test review that incorporates polleverywhere.com so teachers can see what part of the lesson is confusing and needs more attention.
3. Since students and parents are four times more likely to respond to an text message compared to voice mail (HomeworkNOW.com), text messages from school could possibly bridge some of the gap between parent and teacher communications. Using a website like HomeworkNOW.com can send alerts, homework assignments, quizzes, notice of school functions in the form of a text to students who either missed a class or as a reminder for students. This can help make our schools "greener" by cutting down on the amount of paper we now see being used.
Yes, cell phones can be distracting and be used in malicious ways, but i believe they can be harnessed into learning tools instead. I also believe cell phones in school will play a significant part in student learning in the future.
Resources:
http://www.ny1.com/content/news_beats/117128/teachers--class-promotes-cell-phones-as-next-great-learning-tools
HomeworkNOW.com
Ok, don't hate me. First off, in my mind the beginning of your post on the negative effects of the use of cell phones completely trumps your advantages. Do you really think that students will use their cell phones to take notes? Also, schools supply classrooms with calculators so there is not a need for students to use the calculators on their phones. Second, just like many methods used to make students more excited about learning they in time becoming boring for students. As teachers, it's indeed difficult at times to make content more exciting, but will cell phones really make the students exciting about the content or more exciting because now they can talk to their friend in Algebra who is suppose to be using their phone as a calculator but also is clearly missuing this privalege. Third, although HomeworkNOW.com actually seems like a very useful tool, is it necessary? Many schools have systems where parents and students can access their grades and missed work on the Internet. You gave resources used for the use of cellphones but i'm not convinced that they are necessary in the classroom.
ReplyDeleteMy main question for you comes from your third bullet of your opening statement. "Not all students will have access to a cellphone".
What are you going to do if you have an activity for students to complete using their cellphones and poor Bobby comes from a family that can hardly afford basic needs let alone a cell phone? Is this fair to him?
Hi Rob!
ReplyDeleteI'm glad that you acknowledged the pros and cons to cell phone usage in the classroom, but like Breanna, I believe the cons truly outweigh any pros that exist.
Instead of restating Breanna's concerns and questions, I'll go another direction. In your classroom, how will you remain certain that students are actually using the technology on their cell phones for educational purposes? Students can be pretending to use their phone as a calculator, but really could be using Facebook or text messaging their friend in another classroom. I truly do not see how a teacher can stop instances like this from happening. Even with today's technology (computers), we cannot be sure if students are doing their work or playing games on the Internet without seeing firsthand.
So, what would your strategies be?
Brenda, of course I don't hate you. I appreciate your thorough criticism of my post. I do agree with the negative aspects of cell phones in class. However, my point is simple. I see cell phone use in the classroom inevitable. The forces of technology will quite possible surpass the bulky lap tops and desktops and our cell phones will become the extension of ourselves in the form of an "electronic clone". To respond to your main question, I agree the availability of cell phones to every student could pose a problem but possibly the school district could help pay or fundraisers organized to help pay or defray the costs.
ReplyDeleteMy strategies for cell phones in the class would be the same the strategies for computer use is today. Close observation and control of what students are doing seem the best strategy today.